Erin Maessen

Cat and Bird

It comes in the dark: a small, tentative sound, a soft cry that cannot fail to be heard. It is the darker side of morning, not yet 6 am, and the cat is ready to be fed. Despite that precise, plaintive note that nature has evolved to stir human sympathies, I try to ignore him for a while, smothered by sleep—lie still long enough and he might too. Silence. A soft thump and a sudden weight on my legs. Then, out of the darkness, a rumbling purr. It is the sound of roaring fires, warm lights, and mulled wine in the coldest winter, the sound of joy and comfort and love. I reach out, fumble to stroke his furry face and feel the tickle of whiskers. There is no staying in bed now.

He races me to the kitchen, doubling back if for some unfathomable human reason I take too long—pausing to pull on my dressing gown, perhaps, or switch on a light. When I pull the blind, however, he is distracted from his quest for food. Hind legs on the bench seat, he stands with paws against the glass, transfixed by the world outside. We are well past the dawn chorus, but the garden is still alive with bird activity. Three fat tūī chase one another in the kōwhai tree that is beginning to turn yellow with flowers, a starling pops in and out of the bird house where he may or may not decide to raise his children, a pair of blackbirds hop across the lawn and peck at the windfall lemons, and from the gutter a rude gaggle of mynas cackle amongst themselves. Alfie—that streak of ginger fur leaning on my windowsill—is fascinated by it all, eager to join in, and, to be honest, a little afraid. He’s really just a baby, six months old and still jumping at shadows or the rustle of a leaf, still looking at the vast bulk of a mynah or a tūī as something to admire from a safe distance, not only unobtainable, but beyond the scope of desire. I stroke his head, feeling my own whispers of discomfort as I watch my furry predator watching the creatures that he must, surely, soon look on as prey. I am not ready, have not found a way to live with that disquiet except to hope naively that the day will never come when I am presented with a small feathery corpse.

    

In 2015, the government announced the aspiration to create a predator-free New Zealand by the year 2050. The basic goal: to eradicate seven species—possums, stoats, ferrets, weasels, and three kinds of rat (Ship, Norway, and Kiore). Over the next few years, momentum gathered, community groups, government departments, and large charitable organisations alike chipping away at their own little pieces of the 268,021 km2 puzzle. For me though, the start of that shining objective was a few years earlier, in a two-page spread in The Listener by science writer Rebecca Priestley. I still have the clipping carefully saved, the ripped edges jagged, pressed into a clear file page in a drawer. Above a photo of the pristine lake that forms the centre of the predator-free sanctuary Zealandia is the headline “Out, damn pests”. Below, Sir Paul Callaghan’s vision for a New Zealand entirely free of introduced mammalian pests is laid out.

I still remember my amazement when I read this article for the first time. For years, I had believed that the highest pinnacle, the greatest achievement conservation could hope for was the creation of a predator-free sanctuary, like Zealandia in Wellington, or my local Lake Rotokare Reserve, where I spent many teenage hours as a volunteer. Now here was a brilliant scientist suggesting that we could do more, much more—who believed we could turn our entire country into one vast sanctuary. In my head, the New Zealand he thought was possible was a lush, overflowing paradise, vibrant with colours and life, native creatures taking back every corner from which they had been brutally forced by the arrival of humans and our mammalian companions. When a few years later the government decided we all would share in this collective dream, it seemed that we must succeed. Reality though? Who knows. Eleven years on, we are only a small way into a massive work in progress. Eleven years on, and the reality is my cat watching the birds he hasn’t yet learned to kill, rat traps in the backyard, and a feeling of unease that these disparate things will never be fully resolved.

    

A few years ago, I worked as a tutor for an undergraduate science course where one of my jobs was to engage the students in online discussion. When we got to the module on predator-free New Zealand, where the students examined evidence from different groups to decide whether the government’s 2050 goal might really be achievable, I liked to ask what I unashamedly called “the elephant in the room question”. “What do you think,” I typed, “about the place of cats in all this? Cats are not mentioned in the official targets, just rats, mustelids, and possums. Is this a mistake? What should we do about cats?” And then at the bottom I added, “Do you have a cat yourself?”

The students were quick to declare their allegiance. “I’m a cat lover”, “I have two cats at home”, “Absolutely, I think we need to get rid of cats too—but I’m more of a dog person.” The most common response, perhaps to please me in hopes of extra credit, perhaps genuinely, was a mixture of obstinate love and guilt. Variations on the theme of “I love cats, but once my current cat dies, I won’t get another one”. The consensus was clear. People would prefer to imagine a gentle phasing-out of furry felines, a path of least resistance where no unsavoury action would be required and we could focus our attentions on the horrid rats and stoats. It’s not a bad plan for a project that relies so entirely on social licence and grass-roots effort, in a country where 40% of us share our home with one or more feline companions[1]. The flaw, though, is that it might be impossible to go through with. It certainly was for me.

Perhaps I am weak, perhaps the love of native species, the devotion to conservation that was instilled in me almost at birth, does not run as deeply as I thought. All I know is that three years after the death of my beloved childhood cat Sophie, when the raw, wrenching grief had had time to settle, I found myself in a pet shop with the cage door open and a tiny ginger fluffball in my arms. All I know is that no one loves you as devotedly and uncomplicatedly as your pets, and I was desperate for my life to contain that love again. Despite my doubts, I took him home, called him Alfie, let him sit on my shoulder and sleep on my bed, and waited anxiously for the inevitable day when his hunting instincts would appear.

    

Many people deny that their cat hunts. Not my tabby, he wouldn’t hurt a fly. Fluffy is far too lazy for hunting. My Matilda gets all the food she needs at home. It can be hard to remember that the furry lump snoozing in the sun is a wild thing at heart; that while you may think of them as your baby, they also have a secret life. In the dark, in the wild, do you really know what your cat does when he leaves your side? The data says no. A study carried out in Dunedin in 2009[2] found that cats bring home an average of 13 pieces of prey each year, killing an indiscriminate mix of birds, reptiles, and, yes, rodents. Worse than that, though, is the finding of a joint study by University of Georgia and National Geographic[3], which used ‘kitty cams’ to determine that cats only bring home around 21% of their kills—so if you are presented with one dead bird or the bloody tail of a lizard, chances are your cat has caught four others in secret. Forest and Bird are currently advocating for a Cat Management Act[4], which would legislate responsible cat ownership in much the same way as we do with dogs. Compulsory desexing and microchipping, and a limit of three cats per household are all measures that could help limit the size of the unwanted cat population. And while the main advantage of a national Cat Act is reducing the number of pet cats that spill over into becoming feral or strays, it also offers a chance to better educate owners.

Of course there is another option: keeping your cat inside and away from wildlife altogether. In some countries, indoor-only cats are common. In others, outdoor play might happen in a closed-in ‘catio’—enclosures that look, somewhat ironically, like a large bird aviary—although these are designed more for the safety of the cat than their potential prey. Neither option is very common in New Zealand, and I’m not entirely sure how I feel about keeping a cat inside. While they may be safer, is an indoor cat really as happy as its free-to-roam counterpart? Is it right to keep an animal and then restrict its natural behaviours in this way? I’m just not sure. But it’s hard to imagine this becoming the norm here in New Zealand, when for many months of the year we leave our doors and windows wide open.

What else can the responsible or guilt-ridden owner do to reduce their cat’s desire to hunt? Here are a few of the most effective measures, although even these are debated: feed him on a high-protein diet, so that hunger isn’t a factor. Spend at least 10 minutes a day playing an engaging game with him, such as chasing a feather on a string (even though it feels uncannily like you are training him to catch and kill wild things). Keep him inside at dawn and dusk when birds are most active and overnight when they tend to be vulnerable—birds don’t see in the dark. Cats do. Fit him out in a collar with a “clown” ruffle which gives birds an extra visual clue of danger’s approach. A single bell doesn’t always work, but two or more together have a better effect. When all else fails…turn to hope or hopeless denial. Perhaps you can find another way to balance out your guilt.

    

Sometimes on a weekend, I walk with my mum on her neighbourhood trap line: 14 traps along a section of the Waiwhakaiho riverbank. Predator Free Taranaki, our local division of the project, started off using paid contractors to check trap lines, but that was never going to be sustainable long term—this is a project that lives or dies on the enthusiasm of the local community. Mum answered the call for locals to take over the lines early on and since then the trap network has spread as all kinds of people get involved. The local Catholic priest installing two traps at the presbytery. School children trapping alongside their sports field. A pair of elderly neighbours competing over who would catch the first rat in their new traps. All over the city, new links are being added, a tightening noose on the rodent population.

Further afield, other projects are working towards the same goal, each trying to solve a few of the challenges that will have to be overcome to clear an entire country of mammalian pests: The Miramar Peninsula project, a first stage in creating a predator-free capital; Waiheke Island, aiming to be the largest predator-free island to date; South Westland, where two mighty rivers may be the key to keeping pests from re-invading a remote area of bush. Whakatāne, Whangārei, Dunedin, Banks Peninsula, among others, are all parts of a bigger picture that starts with locals setting their one backyard trap. With us. And so, on weekends, we walk the trap lines.

My job is recordkeeper, entering data for each trap into an app that collates information on various Predator Free projects: species caught, bait used, any interference or damage to the trap. I get record duty because, despite celebrating the death of every rat, mouse, and stoat, I have to admit a certain squeamishness when it comes to actually seeing the decaying corpse—yet another source of guilt to push silently aside. I watch from a safe distance while Mum extracts the remains of a rat from a trap and flings it deep into the undergrowth.

“One Norway rat—look at its small ears and short tail!”

“I’ll take your word for it.”

She rebaits with a blob of peanut butter, screws the trap box closed (an important protection against nosy humans in this very public area), and we move on to the next box, 50 metres further down the path.

“Still set, but the bait’s gone. Probably slugs—there are slime trails all over this one.”    

Mum counts the successful catches on the wall beside her desk at work, a row of little felt tip drawings—rat, mouse, stoat—beside red tally marks. On days when I have to work and miss out on the trap walk, she sends me texts to celebrate any kills—a line of emojis: rat, mouse, skull and crossbones. I return exclamation marks, thumbs up, smiley faces. We are celebrating an exchange of death for life, rat for bird. I have never had any doubt that this is the cost of conservation, never lacked certainty that this is not only necessary but right. Yet there is something uncomfortable here.

Why does conservation, grounded in our love of the birds, insects, and reptiles which have evolved on this strange island, rely so strongly on death? If I think about it too hard it doesn’t quite reconcile. As a child, I was a member of the Kiwi Conservation Club; growing up I loved animals obsessively; as a teenager I got my hands dirty (literally) helping with pest monitoring at predator-free Rotokare Reserve. I support 1080 as the best of the limited options we have at the moment. I don’t mind killing rats, in fact I’m excited to do it. Even so, there is something here that I cannot quite grasp.

I was 25 before I became aware that conservation in other countries does not always rely so heavily on trying to destroy undesirable species, that in other places, keen volunteers might contribute to conservation efforts in ways that don’t involve killing things. Here, it’s a fact of life—bird life, that is.

    

My first experience of a New Zealand without mammalian predators came when I was 13 and we took a trip to Tiritiri Matangi Island. Situated in the Hauraki Gulf, this 22-hectare island has been pest-free since 1993[5]. After hearing people talk about their visits there, I was desperate to go too—to experience birds I had only seen in pictures.

“Just choose a spot in the bush, sit still and wait,” we were told. We stepped off the ferry, wandered perhaps a hundred metres into the trees, and did just that. Slowly, the bush around us came to life. Bellbird, stitchbird, and saddleback flitted through the trees, going about their private lives utterly undisturbed by our silent, ecstatic presence. I had never seen a patch of bush so vibrant and full of bird noise, although happily this is becoming more common, and today you don’t even have to step off the mainland to see it.  Slowly, we wandered the island’s trails, stopped, listened, walked again. By the afternoon, we had reached the long sloping lawn beneath the cheerful red and white lighthouse. A pair of takahē wandered into view, cropping grass in the warmth of the summer sun. They strode across the lawn on their sturdy red legs and clawed feet, and came close to peer at my camera with interest, even raising a chipped beak to poke inquisitively at the strange object. Tilting the lens away from danger, I tried to capture the beauty of their many-coloured feathers: greens, blues, a tuft of white at the tail. The takahē were round, contented, at home on their island without threat of predators, and not lacking for enthusiastic admirers. This was 2005. Paul Callaghan’s endorsement of New Zealand’s “moonshot”, an entire country emptied of predatory mammals, was still years away, and this small island a short ferry trip from the yachts and buildings of Auckland’s waterfront seemed the pinnacle of everything we could hope to achieve for our native species. A time capsule, a living museum, a gated community mirroring those we had driven past that morning on the way to the port—this time to keep not wealthy humans but our most precious and fading native creatures safe.

    

At home, Alfie lounges on my lap in the evenings, purring ecstatically as he reaches a paw to gently pat my face. During the day, he springs up and down his very own floating shelves, or sprints like a mad thing to chase a jingly ball. I open the back door and hear the rattle of the two bells and metal name tag on his collar as he potters around in the flowerbeds or zooms up the largest tree in the garden. So far, the birds fluttering by are just one of many distractions. Occasionally he tries to stalk a blackbird—and is spotted before he gets within five metres of it. I’m free to relax, to watch, to keep the furry ginger predator at my feet in a separate compartment from the smaller, furry grey predators we are killing in traps along the back fence. I watch the starling build his nest, put out sugar water for the tūī, and enjoy the antics of the wax-eyes in the camellia by the kitchen window. I help with the annual garden bird survey, read excitedly about a new species of lizard being discovered, and dream of a day when the bubbles of wilderness that are Kāpiti Island, Zealandia, Titritiri Matangi, and all the others, spill out across the entire country and join into one. I wish with all my heart for a predator-free New Zealand, and when the cat jumps on my bed each night and curls his warm body up against my legs, I feel that I could not bear a life without him. The elephant in the room is right here in our homes, meowing for food in the morning as the dawn chorus comes to a close and a new day starts again. And I feel I will never come closer than this to holding all these disparate, conflicting things in my hands at one time.

It’s dark, and I hear the soft tentative sound of a quiet meow.

 



[1] Companion Animals New Zealand. (2024). Companion animals in New Zealand: NZ pet data report 2024. (ISBN: 978-1-0670191-3-6). https://www.companionanimals.nz/2024-nz-pet-data-report

[2] van Heezik, Y. et al. Do domestic cats impose an unsustainable harvest on urban bird populations? Biological Conservation 143 (2010) 121–130

[3] Wagstaff, K. (2012). Kitty cams reveal housecoats to be rapacious killing machines. Time. https://techland.time.com/2012/08/08/kitty-cams-reveal-house-cats-to-be-rapacious-killing-machines/#ixzz22yvF64oM

[4] Geary, A. (2023). Time to act for cats. Forest and Bird. https://www.forestandbird.org.nz/resources/time-act-cats

[5] Tiritiri Matangi. (2001). The Sanctuary. https://www.tiritirimatangi.org.nz/the-sanctuary/





Erin Maessen

Erin Maessen is a writer based in Taranaki, and a full-time librarian and prolific reader. She writes a mixture of memoir, personal essay and creative nonfiction, focusing on science and societal issues. Erin's favourite animal is the longfin eel, which was also the subject of her Master's thesis at Te Herenga Waka-Victoria University in 2019.