Jillian Sullivan

Consent, What Consent?

Note: This essay contains mentions of sexual violence that readers may find distressing.

How will she say the words to tell the police what happened to her? 

Fifteen is so full of memories: the first time sliding on the snow; the first time squashed in the car with her New Zealand cousins; the first lifting of her greenstone.

My granddaughter walks towards that room with her aunt, towards police officers and social workers.

And then she speaks…

Bonfire

Poet and philosopher John O’Donohue[1] wrote, “When we suffer, our sense of belonging is broken.”

When belonging breaks, it shears the bonds of place and family and memories and future dreams. This shearing is the beginning of a new way of being.

Not asked for. Not sought.

 

You walk amongst friends and you don’t talk about what happened.

You haven’t the words yet. You’re not ready yet. You don’t want to conjure the images, the darkness.

You want to forget, but you’re not the same person.

You look the same, perhaps your friends think you are the same, but inside is this disruption of belonging.

You don’t know if talking about it lessens the grief or deepens it.

You don’t know if by walking around with it memories will begin to subside—become not so much a serrated knife inside but a hole you edge around.

This edging, this seeking to forget.

And also: this fucking bonfire of anger.

 

Grandma, could you write about this?   

   The numbers and histories of sexual abuse.

   The long-reaching implications of abuse.

 

How to become an activist

Read about injustice.

Work out what you can do to help.

Do that.

 

Attend meetings, email councils and CEOs (of fast food companies, sports teams, hotels).

Write to politicians.

Write to my granddaughter’s school with three requests:

            Make consent education mandatory,

            Set up an online anonymous survey to gauge the extent of abuse, and

            Educate parents on consent.

Wake up at 5.30 am to think about abuse and who to write to and what to say and how else to make the world safer for our precious young. (“Welcome to my world,” a sexual abuse counsellor says to me).

Our family has a history of sexual abuse. It’s not in the past as we thought. It’s in this generation with a vengeance, fed by porn, silenced by fear, misunderstood by our own cultural understandings of rape.

Mental distress of students is the key concern of secondary schools but people in charge of those schools aren’t talking enough about sexual abuse.

When 90% of victims don’t report it, abuse remains the dark story in children’s lives.

Silence is not consent. No resistance is not consent.

I tell a friend I’m working on a poster about sexual consent and how if the high school doesn’t send it out to parents, I’ll still send it anywhere I can. And then he says his daughter was raped when she was 15. 

He stands there in my garden and tells me about her battle with drugs and depression. And I recall how Rose, who lives beside me and whose daughter Polly was raped at 11 and died much too young, had said, “Is there a family in our country that isn’t touched by sexual abuse?”

The police interview

“We sat outside the police station for a bit gathering confidence,” my daughter writes. “When I took her to make the initial statement a few nights ago it was dark. The daylight today makes it all seem more real.”

There are two detectives and two social workers in the blue-couched room.

The female detective says that there will be breaks if they are needed.

There’s a monitor room next door where the male detective will sit and record. The female detective will extract the details needed.

One of the social workers thanks my daughter for providing a safe supportive environment for her niece to speak up.

“The acknowledgement rings true, and yet, and yet…my mind works overtime thinking of different what if’s. What if she had not lived with us this year, or stayed with friends that night? This never would have happened.”

The lake has white caps—a storm on the way. It’s only an hour and the call comes. It’s over.

“She did well,” the male detective says. 

The interview was okay, my granddaughter says. The worst bit was being made to say the proper terms for all the body parts (penis—ugh, so gross). 

“After the interview,” my daughter writes, “she observed the streets from her lost-innocence eyes and felt nostalgia—for hanging at McDonalds, skateboarding down that lane, Luma festival over there, swimming in the lake. I bought a passionfruit sorbet to share and we sat by the lake on a bench. She said it felt like the end of a movie.”  

A few terms we become familiar with:

Cultural misconceptions; categorical denier.

The cultural misconceptions around rape, for instance, become important to overcome when jurors make decisions at a trial.

Sometimes a young person doesn’t fight back, but instead freezes, disassociates, is unresponsive.

Sometimes there are no injuries.

Sometimes a person doesn’t reveal what happened for days or for years.

Sometimes a person presents as “normal” afterwards. They may be doing what they need to do to survive.

A rapist is often not a stranger but a family member, a friend, a family friend, a friend’s friend.

A categorical denier is one who, instead of admitting to the offence or excusing or minimizing, completely denies what happened. Accuses the survivor of lying.

Around 2–10% of accusations can be labelled false (this includes cases not prosecuted due to lack of evidence). Some 57% of men deny their actions before trial. Even after they’re jailed on hard evidence, 21% continue to categorically deny.

 

He denies it.

 

“Categorical denial is a strategy used to reduce negative consequences such as a sense of shame or the fear of losing family support (Ware and Blagden, 2020[2]).”

What comes after

“The process of making a rape complaint has profound, far-reaching and generally negative consequences on complainants’ wellbeing and lives, as a result of which common sense suggests there is little incentive to make a false allegation (Tinsley, 2021[3]).”

My granddaughter dreams the perpetrator’s mother puts her arms around her and hugs her.

Instead, his mother tells people the girl is lying. The father sends texts threatening legal action. 

My daughter writes to the mother but doesn’t send it.

“I know you are protective of your son. I understand you will be heartbroken. We are also heartbroken.”

 

“The worst part was the aftermath,” my granddaughter tells me. “His family spreading all this stuff. It was so overwhelming. I didn’t want to say anything at school but the rumours were already there. Boys saying ‘girls lie, that’s what they do’. There’s no way to prove what happened. It’s one of the barriers to coming forward, the way you get treated.”

The mother of one of the students tells her son, “You know she might not be lying.”

She tells him when she was at school, a teacher abused her and when she told people they shunned her, called her a liar. Years later, that teacher was convicted of sexual assault.

The detective says there is not enough hard evidence for a conviction. It’s my granddaughter’s word against that of the boy.

“I believe her 100%,” the detective says.

She can still take it to court, if she chooses.

Neighbour Rose Riddell, retired District and Family Court Judge, says[4]: “You must weigh up the importance of going ahead in the hope a jury will believe her against the stress of a trial and the risk of a not guilty verdict. The boy’s lawyer can choose whether to have a judge alone or a jury trial and almost always they go for a jury—who are generally more reluctant to convict. For some people it is enough to take a complaint to police. If he ever comes to their attention again and is charged, then the earlier complaint can be used as evidence of propensity.”

My granddaughter chooses not to go to court.

Just one of the reasons:

—It will get dragged on for years and the justice system only prosecutes if there’s hard evidence—which there isn’t—so it will never fully be over and I’ll never get closure or justice. 

 

There’s no restorative justice.

No counselling for him.

No apology.

No comfort for her.

Nor for those of us who love her.

Instead, an awareness and distress at how often this is happening to our young people.

They must remake their own lives and reside there, in the flame of their own truth: the beautiful dispossessed glowing again, as they must and will.

 

We are broken and our families are broken. And also, we are shining. We are not defined by what has happened to us. But we can be defined by how we stand up to it. 

How do we transform ourselves—let alone the society we live in?

Is it belonging to place? Is it to see yourself as part of a tribe?

How do we anchor ourselves in a belonging so deep that we are at all times responsible for the sphere of our actions?

Maybe the school will help

“What did you want to get out of this meeting?” the deputy principal asks. And I think of my list and what it asked of the school and how I thought you could just want something that was right and it could happen without the layers of complexity and time constraints and competing issues and red tape and parents’ opposition and the youth of students and how they needed protecting.

“I want the school to do an anonymous survey to bring out the level of sexual harm and also to move towards healing.”

“What would be the benefit?” she asks. “Just the shock value to show the community something needs to be done. Is that worth any trauma it puts the girls through to achieve that?”

(According to Berliner[5]: “Establishing the frequency of a problem has everything to do with how seriously it is taken.”)

“It’s not just about the data,” I say. I tell them of my interview with my sister, Kathy Masters, who was Director of Redress for sexual harm in institutions in Queensland State. Kathy said, “Even if you don’t know who the girls are, even if you can’t reach them with a counsellor, the very act for them of writing down what happened begins the healing process.”

“The problem is deeper than a school can address,” the head of health and PE says. “It’s all of society’s problem, and all of society has to help.”

Yet, as Kayla Stewart writes in her doctoral thesis, “Sexual violence must be addressed at the societal level, but “while we wait or work for social change people are still being victimized[6].”

Doing what I can to help 

My daughters point out my poster on consent needs colour, it needs design.

I trust I will find the right designer. I trust the yellow-gold colour I imagine.

I trust that one page will tell a person in a glance what positive consent is: not silence, not reluctance, not incapacitation, but an equality of desire.

On the fifth night of edits I push complete on the design.

The first poster my granddaughter and friends put up in the school bus bay.

University student associations around New Zealand say thank you, we will put it up.

NZ Police forwards it to the Strategic Communications team.

Hospitality NZ: “I have shared your poster with the Don’t Guess the Yes team and will ensure it is also shared with our team internally.”

From NZ Rugby, no reply.

From many, many boys’ colleges, no reply.

The Managing Director of McDonalds NZ and Pacific Islands replies with a no, “But please be assured we treat the subject of consent very seriously. It forms part of the training we provide to staff.”

My local MP thanks me for my research, and sends my email to the Education Minister, the Honourable Erica Stanford.

From the Education Minister, nothing.

From Marama Davidson MP, former Minister for the Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence: “Thank you so much for providing your poster as an educational tool on positive consent…I am very happy to support this work and will share it around.”

From TIKA, the website for legal justice: “Thank you for your wonderful poster.”

From others: “I have printed out five”, “‘I have put them up in the police station”, “‘I have put them up in our offices”, “‘I’ll put them up at our school.”

What we know now

One in three New Zealand women are sexually assaulted[7].

One in eight men.

Two in five transgender people.

One in three university students.

Kayla Stewart[8] writes in her thesis: “Sexual violence at an Aotearoa university is a significant risk for all students and can cause serious impacts.”

“The perpetrator,” writes journalist Michelle Duff,[9] “will most likely be a young male student, who will assault his victim while they are drunk, asleep, or otherwise incapacitated.”

Stewart[10]: “Incapacitation was the most commonly reported tactic with 69.4% (n = 667) of the victimised sample reporting having experienced this.”

And there riding ahead of me…

One morning there’s a link to a documentary and petition up online.

“It is no secret that there is an epidemic of sexual violence within secondary schools in New Zealand. I am an 18-year-old student—I see it every day and have experienced it first-hand.”

This is Billie Carey and, like me, she is asking for our school to establish an anonymous sexual harm survey, and create programmes and initiatives that are focused on teaching consent and providing a strong support system for victims.

Since starting SASH (Students Against Sexual Harm) with a friend and releasing the documentary, Billie has been approached by countless students and former students with their stories of sexual assault.

She wrote to the Board of Trustees, “The most heartbreaking discovery I made was that the majority of rape incidents happen to year 9 and 10 students (13–15-year-olds).

These boys get off scot-free, Billie says. They get awarded leadership positions and scholarships while the victims go through years of therapy to be able to be in the same room as their rapists and not have a panic attack.

Talking round the table

I’m with my granddaughter and her friend. I tell them how two women—Alison Mau, a broadcaster and journalist, and barrister Zoe Lawton—are putting together a website, Tika. The aim is to help change the low reporting rates on sexual violence. Tika, meaning justice and fairness.

Survivors of sexual harm will be able to securely record the details and the name of the harmer, I tell the girls. If the database finds a match with anyone who has been harmed by the same person, even years later, they’ll take group action with the help of Tika’s lawyers—for free.

“That’s so good,” the friend says. “That will really help. There are boys at school…the things they’ve done to girls…when they get older they’re going to realise how terrible they’ve been.”

“They’re like predators,” my granddaughter says.  

“One reason for Tika is to act as a deterrent,” I say, “and it will be, especially when boys at school find out about it. Less than 10% of victims lay a complaint with police. The guys think they can get away with it. That’s because if you go ahead with the complaint, it’s a shitshow.” I look across the table at my granddaughter. She is silent for a moment.

“It fucking is,” she says. “It fucking is. It fucking is.”

Who’s protecting who?

“The thing I’m angriest about is the victim shaming,” Billie tells me. “And what I found most upsetting was how quickly male authority figures tried to tone me down, as if it was me that was in the wrong for telling them the names of the boys who had sexually assaulted girls from school. That’s what I don’t understand. Sexual violence is such a problem. Instead of trying to hide it, do something about it.”

Findings from the five-year-long survey into institutional response to sexual abuse in Queensland State showed that children weren’t believed when they reported sexual abuse, my sister tells me. Institutions protected themselves before the needs of the child. (And the same pattern has now been borne out here in the New Zealand Royal Commission of Inquiry[11].)

Are our high schools protecting themselves at the expense of protecting children?

How we speak, and how we speak up

“It’s the harassment at school, the name calling, the rape jokes. The older boys do it, the Year 12s and 13s, including students in leadership positions,” Billie tells me. “They set this culture for the younger boys coming into the school and it keeps perpetuating. It’s in this culture of misogynistic language that male students go on to sexually assault and rape.”

I ask Billie about her experience of having to stand up, to become an activist.

“People want you to be more polite, but nothing gets done that way. You have to make people uncomfortable to have change. You have to keep being that person who’s pushing the boundary.”

I turn to John O’Donoghue[12] again: “A secret exchange of Spirit continually flows between us,” he writes. “A person, then, has the choice to take on the sufferings of another and carry them.”

Does taking action help carry another’s burden of grief and shame?

Does it help give forbearance?

“You can give your granddaughter my phone number,” Billie says. “Please tell her if she ever needs to talk, I’ll drop everything to talk with her.”

The end, and also a beginning

My granddaughter has been with us for a year, and now it’s time for home.

We sit on the grass outside the airport: grandmother, aunts, uncle, teenagers, cousins.

Our girl with her long hair and a backpack on her back. We hug her and take photos in the sun. We walk together with her to the gate.

And now it really does feel like the end of a movie.

All she went through, and all we went through.

Our girl up in the air, and all things. How we wish to be wondrous in front of her.

That’s what we wish.



[1] O’Donohue, John. Eternal Echoes: Celtic Reflections on Our Yearning to Belong. Bantam Books, 1998. 

[2] Ware, Jayson, and Nicholas Blagden. “Men with Sexual Convictions and Denial.” Current Psychiatry Reports, vol. 22, no. 9, 2020, article e51. Springer, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11920-020-01174-z.

[3] Tinsley, Yvette. “The ‘False Allegation’ Misconception in Sexual Violence Cases.” Victoria University of Wellington Law Review, vol. 52, no. 2, 2021, pp. 464–485. 

[4] Retired District and Family Court Judge Rose Riddell made these comments in response to my questions.

[5] Berliner, Lucy. “Facts or Advocacy Statistics.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence, vol.7, no.1, 1992, p.121

[6] Stewart, Kayla G. “I Guess That’s Part of Life”: The Sexual Victimisation of Aotearoa University Students. University of Otago, 2021. PhD dissertation, p. 111. 

[7] HELP Auckland. Sexual Abuse Statistics: Wider Experiences of Sexual Violence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Nov. 2021, https://helpauckland.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/SexualAbuseStatistics-Detailed.pdf

[8] See reference at footnote 6.

[9] Duff, Michelle. “Campus Sex Assault Shame.” The Press, 6 June 2019, pp. 16–17.

[10] See reference at footnote 6.

[11] The Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse in State Care and in the Care of Faith-based Institutions was established in New Zealand in 2018.

[12] See reference at footnote 1.





Jillian Sullivan

Jillian Sullivan lives in Central Otago. Her thirteen published books include essays, novels, memoir, short stories and poetry. She has a Master of Creative Writing through Massey University, teaches creative nonfiction in New Zealand (and for seven summers in America). Her awards include the Juncture Memoir Award in America, the NZ Society of Authors Beatson Fellowship, and the Kathleen Grattan Prize for a sequence of poems.  Mother of five, grandmother of thirteen, co-builder of her strawbale home in the Ida Valley. Her latest book is  Map for the Heart—Ida Valley Essays (Otago University Press 2020). www.jilliansullivan.co.nz