The lake did not exist when my father was born, but by the time he died, it was the deepest body of water in the county. This is the kind of fact people on the Iron Range say with something adjacent to pride. We made a hole so big it became geography. The mining company called what they removed overburden—the worthless rock lying on top of the ore—and for sixty years they stacked it in grey hills at the edge of town. Then the ore ran out, and the pumps shut off, and the groundwater rose into the pit the way water seeps into any wound.
I came back in June to empty my father’s house. Everyone said, “Empty the house,” like the house was the container, but the house was fine. He had been the container and everything in the house was just what had spilled out.
He kept ore on the windowsill above the kitchen sink. Not decoratively: decoration would have required him to admit he found it beautiful. A row of taconite pellets in a jelly jar, grey-black and perfectly round, like the eggs of something patient. As a kid I believed they were eggs. I used to hold the jar to the light and check for movement. He let me believe it for years. I understood later this was his version of tenderness: he would not lie to me, but he would let a good error stand.
The pit lake is a quarter mile past the last street with a name. There's a sign the city put up in the nineties, with white text on brown, the font state parks use, and mild warnings: “NO LIFEGUARD. WATER DEPTH EXCEEDS 400 FEET. SUBMERGED HAZARDS.” Somebody has been adding to it with a paint pen for thirty years. Under “SUBMERGED HAZARDS,” in careful cursive they’ve added: “The whole twentieth century.”
Which is roughly accurate. When the pumps stopped, the company abandoned what wasn't worth hauling up the switchback road. A locomotive, allegedly. Ore cars. The maintenance shed beside the haul road at the first bench, tar-paper roof and all. The water that rose over them is mine-pit water, filtered through a hundred feet of fractured rock. It is clear in a way lake water has no business being. Clear like the air in a dream where you can suddenly read. On a still day, you can float on your back in the middle of it, roll over, look down, and see the haul road descending below you in long pale ramps, curve after curve into a blue that stops being a colour and starts being a distance.
The kids call diving there visiting. As in, “We went visiting Saturday.” They freedive down to the first bench, forty feet, touch the roof of the shed, and come up screaming with cold. The shed is the whole ritual. Touch the shed, you've visited. Nobody goes to the second bench. There's a story about the second bench and a boy in 1988 and, like all Range stories, it has been polished by handling until you can't tell what it originally depicted.
I hadn't been in the water since I left twenty-two years before. But I'd spent nine days sorting a dead man's spilled contents into “DONATE” and “KEEP”. I called a third pile “ASK MOM” even though there was no one left to ask. On the tenth day, I put on my swimsuit under my clothes the way I did when I was eleven, like a secret, like armour. I walked past the sign about the twentieth century and down the old grade to the water.
Here is what I will say about mine-pit water: it does not welcome you. Lake water welcomes you. Lake water is full of life and rot and warmth in layers, fish nibbling, weeds like wet hair. Lake water is biotic; it has opinions about you. The pit is forty-nine degrees Fahrenheit at the surface in June and contains, as far as I can tell, nothing alive but the idea of the town. You enter it and your body immediately files a formal complaint and then goes quiet. Then you are just a warm thing suspended over a cold industrial ruin, which—I checked, treading water, ears aching—is also a reasonable description of the town itself, and possibly of grief.
I floated out over the haul road. I could see it the whole way, dropping under me in its patient ramps. I thought about the trucks that used to climb it, loaded, twenty-four hours a day, my father in one of them for eleven years. He liked the night shift; he said the pit at night was the only place on earth with no weather, and I thought about how the road was still in perfect condition. That's the thing nobody tells you about drowned places. Nothing weathers. No frost, no sun, no ploughs. The road down there will outlast every road up here. We built our most permanent things by accident, at the bottom of a hole, while trying to get something else out of it.
I dove.
I am not a strong diver. I am a tall woman with more surface area than sense, and forty feet is a long way down when the water is stealing your heat like it's owed. But the shed came up under me out of the blue distance, tar-paper roof furred with pale silt, and I touched it. The silt came off on my fingers like dust off a piano in a house where someone has recently died. Exactly like that. I had been touching that dust for nine days.
And here is the part I have not told anyone, and I am telling you only because you are a literary journal and therefore a kind of confessional with a rejection rate.
There was a light in the shed.
Not a light. I know it was not a light. Forty feet down, oxygen-starved, pupils blown wide in the blue, the brain manufactures phosphenes. At least, that was what I told myself. My father would have said, “Your eyes are lying to you, which is different from you lying,” and let the good error stand. But through the gap where the shed door has hung open since 1962, there was a small warm yellow glow, the exact colour of a kitchen window seen from the end of a driveway in winter. The colour of someone is home. It did not flicker. It waited, the way lit windows wait, without asking anything of you, entirely certain you will come in eventually.
I did not go in. I went up.
I sat on the old grade in the sun for a long time, shaking in a pleasant way, and then I walked back to the house and finished the kitchen. The jelly jar of taconite went in the “KEEP” pile, obviously. I held it up to the light first. Old habit. Checking for movement.
Here is what I think, for whatever a thought is worth once it's been forty feet down: the company took the ore and left the overburden, and they were wrong about which was which. The worthless rock they stacked at the edge of town is where the blueberries grow now, where the poplars came in on their own, where I forage in August with my son, who believes that the grey hills are natural, ancient, that they have always been there. I let the error stand. The valuable part they shipped away became steel beams and Buicks, and is now rust in landfills in states I will never visit. The hole they left filled up with the clearest water in Minnesota and a road built to last forever and a shed where, on one afternoon in June, something kept a light on.
Overburden, it turns out, is just what the future is called by people who can't see it yet.
I drove home with the jar in the cupholder. Every so often, at a red light, I'd glance down and check it. You'd understand if you'd grown up there. On the Range we know better than anyone: you can call a thing worthless, or dead, or empty. It doesn't stop what's inside from waiting.