I first heard about kintsugi in Mackenzi Lee’s The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue. I’ve subsequently come across it in the ‘Good Damage’ episode of BoJack Horseman and in the series finale of Killing Eve. A beautiful concept, and one I’ve been grappling with for months. In this day and age, with just a few clicks, you can find yourself face-to-screen with an agent or algorithm tailor-made to validate you. You don’t need to look far to find a post about how self-care is not selfish and how you have to vigorously cut toxic people off and protect your peace and bla bla bla. Of course there is the converse argument. ‘Community’ and ‘third space’ have become ultra-buzzwords. There are constant reminders that building and being in a village requires self-sacrifice and inconvenience. Where does one draw the line? Or, to bring it back to the Japanese art: what cracks can be filled with gold, and which are better left alone?
I’m not a religious person. As God and I increasingly got into one-sided screaming matches, with long bouts of not talking to each other and eventually an irretrievable break up, I was lost. I didn’t know how to fill my mornings if not with prayer. I didn’t know where to cast my cares. Nothing was holy or sacred anymore. I might have survived all of that and been okay if I could still manage to have faith. But faith in what? For a while, it was in the ultimate love of my life. I replicated a lot of my religious teaching in romance. My thinking was, if we’re made in God’s image, then the person would also want the same things that my former Lord and Saviour did: reverence, dedication, commitment, the promise to change myself and my life until it was pleasing to them, and sacrifice. Whatever it cost, I wanted to belong to someone. This is obviously not sustainable as I repeatedly found out. But I still managed to come out of those situations having learned the wrong lesson. I concluded that one person, mortal or otherwise, cannot be the centre of my existence and source of my personhood. So it had to be multiple people.
Enter friendship. I approached it like venture capitalism. The idea was to spread my essence between as many relationships as I could manage. I wanted there to be subsects of people who only knew me as funny, or serious, or the party friend, or the workaholic, or sensitive. It felt like creating echo chambers for my personality so I could decide, by speaking to someone, who I wanted to be. Inevitably, when you share your life with another person, especially someone you respect enough to be honest with, the cracks will show. They will catch you on a day when you don’t want to put on the regalia of a micro mini skirt and throw a bottle of pink gin in your handbag. You’ll run out of jokes and money and energy. You’ll snap at them because you’re angry at yourself and angry at the world. Texts will go unanswered and calls will be silenced. It will be terrible. Then when you crawl out of the tunnel, they’re there on the other side. You spot the dirt under their nails and realise that they were digging alongside you, fighting to help you to get you out of that dark spot. It’s beautiful and it’s kind and it’s everything.
I’m not making a point about how true love lies in sacrifice and salvation. In fact, that idea is why God and I could never see eye to eye. A few weeks ago, my friend was helping me pack my suitcases to move continents and start my life over. I was reflecting on how real friendship is like the journey home from a party. My feet hurt and I’m grumpy, tired and irritated at everything that stands between me and my bed. I said that I think that version of me is the real me. He said (and this is a direct quote because I immediately rushed to write it down), “but I was at that party with you”. He was making a point about how I’m not any less of myself when I’m happy or I do a nice thing or I’m helpful. Being honest with my friends isn’t just about being sad or a bitch. It is also about sending them minute-long voice notes about a new perfume that I got at a discounted price. It is me reading them excerpts from my teenage poetry book. It is about going to parties and dancing like I do when it’s just the two of us in my bedroom.
The first time I filled in a form and chose the ‘Agnostic’ option instead of ‘Christian’ I felt like someone had pushed me off the edge of the world. And it was even scarier because I couldn’t make myself believe that someone was coming to save me. Faith was a safety net that I had given up. I was afraid about the typical things that one would expect, like going to hell and being a social pariah. But I was most afraid that no one would ever love me completely. And not just love itself but all the things that make up love: grace, forgiveness, understanding. I had lost the guarantee that I could be exactly who I was and still be loved for it.
That’s why I made a religion out of my friends. I think it’s a miracle to love anybody, me most of all. For a long time, I was in constant awe and perpetual gratitude. I would ask questions like, “do you still like me?” and I would only be half joking. I measured my existence against other people. Whenever I felt self-doubt in any sphere of my life I would turn to my community as a yard stick, assuring myself that I couldn’t be that terrible if I was surrounded by so many amazing people. It’s euphoric when you’re on good terms with them and cataclysmic when you’re not. When I would commit biblical sins, I felt like the guilt and shame would kill me. That, coupled with the threat of eternal damnation, made me walk around for weeks with anxiety levels akin to that of an animal being hunted. It was a similar feeling when I disappointed my friends. Actions have consequences and one should definitely feel remorse, but it’s unhealthy to not eat for four days because you’re not speaking to someone. Those sorts of titanic responses can only happen when you think neither you nor the other person is a human being. And I didn’t. I believed my connections were divine and orchestrated by the universe and special. Losing friendships felt like hell, which is to say it felt like losing God all over again.
There’s no remedy I’ve found for being a person that is built for religion but no longer has faith. Heaven terrifies me; the thought of forever always has. Yet there are people with whom I mapped out eternities. Oh well. This is not a piece about how I gave everything and came up empty. I was fulfilled, nurtured, and deeply cared for in those relationships. I was also hurt, angry, and disappointed. Those people probably feel similarly about me. I am not a martyr so I will neither absolve myself of blame nor take on all of it to prove a performative point. I’m an earth sign, meaning stability is my bread and butter. It was so easy to love God because the Bible promises that he remains the same, “yesterday, today, and forever” (Hebrews 13:8). Dependably good, kind, loving, perfect. I wanted to be that and I wanted to love people who are also like that. Finding out that we are all incorrigibly human has been the worst heartbreak of all. It throws me into limbo and puts me in my least favourite place in the world: a liminal space. How do you know when to delete a number if you’re only ever one call away from a complete revolution? What if you tell one joke and they laugh and you remember how it was your favourite sound for years? How everything else in the entire universe faded away when you were laughing with each other? What if they change their minds? What if I change mine? I know that I tried extremely hard in my past friendships, but to borrow from Andrea Gibson in The Year of No Grudges, I “should have tried softer”. Retrospect is a thorough, austere, and brilliant teacher.
Riding a high horse is fun, but there’s nothing quite like having both feet on solid ground. I’ve dismantled my friends’ pedestals and burned their shrines. I want them on solid ground with me. I am, even now, prone to religious guilt so my first thought after an argument is still to hang myself. When I manage to talk myself down from that thought, I go into the kitchen and eat. I journal. I stand barefoot on grass. I’m trying to build my own theocracy with grace at the centre and no omega, no hell or heaven. And with old friends, who knows? I’m not hoping for a reunion. As I’ve said, I’m not a person of faith. But part of embracing my own humanity is accepting the reality that I don’t know everything and I’m not always right. Maybe we will all transform so radically after a few years that we are able to sit opposite each other in the kintsugi class we planned to take. Wouldn’t that be nice? Trying to fix artificial cracks in ceramic knowing that our own relationships, once thought broken, are actually repaired and cemented with love and solid gold.